Agricultural small and medium enterprises (agri-SMEs) play a crucial role in the economic development and advancement of emerging markets. Despite their significance, agri-SMEs still encounter formidable challenges in achieving key growth objectives such as generating revenue and creating employment opportunities. Business Development Services (BDS) are integral in supporting agri-SMEs to grow and thrive, but the effectiveness and cost-efficiency of such programs remain poorly understood.

To address this barrier, ISF analyzed BDS tools and methodologies provided to agri-SMEs in East and West Africa. This report presents findings from an extensive desk review of existing research, an analysis of data collected from 15 BDS provider case studies, and interviews with stakeholders in the space.

This work builds on previous learnings to deepen best practices related to the needs of agri-SMEs and the tools and approaches that could lead to improved BDS provision models. If you’re a BDS provider interested in analyzing the effectiveness, cost-efficiency, and fee coverage of your own services, you can download and utilize our measurement tool here.

Read the full report below, and watch the webinar discussion about this research here.

Related Research

SMEs in Food Systems: A Framework for Engagement

Our framework developed around the structure and key dynamics of food systems – focusing in particular on the role of agri-SMEs – and applied through two country studies in Colombia and Uganda to support the Argidius Foundation.

View Report
Assessing the Cost Efficiency and Effectiveness of Business Development Services for Agri-SMEs

A summary of key findings from our analysis of BDS tools and methodologies provided to agri-SMEs in East and West Africa.

Read More
Landscape Assessment of Agro-Industrial Parks in Uganda

Our landscape assessment in partnership with USAID’s Market Systems and Partnerships (MSP) Activity explores the primary opportunities for donors to further support the Government of Uganda’s ambitious agro-industrialization agenda, a key goal in its latest National Development Plan (NDPIII, 2020).

View Report

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

1

The last decade has seen increasing recognition by policymakers, capital providers, and finance practitioners of the vital role played by agricultural small- and medium-sized enterprises (agri-SMEs) in agriculture and food systems in developing countries, as well as their key challenge of limited access to finance.

In sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia, there is an estimated USD 160 billion demand for financing by ~220,000 agri-SMEs. However, we estimate that only USD 54 billion (~34%) is currently being met through formal finance channels—leaving an annual financing gap of USD 106 billion.

These headline estimates are large, but reflect in numbers what most practitioners have experienced through working with agri-SMEs. Digging beyond numbers, our new State of the Sector report with CASA introduces a more specific view of where the market for agri-SME finance is (and isn’t) clearing.

To add new perspective, this report breaks down the market in a more comprehensive and holistic way to show where finance is specifically flowing, via specific types of products from specific types of funders to specific types of agri-SMEs. The report also presents four long-term change priorities that we see as crucial to systematically closing the USD 106 billion agri-SME financing gap over time.

Related Research

State of the Sector: Agri-Insurance for Smallholder Farmers

A follow up to our 2018 Protecting Growing Prosperity report, we take stock of the current state of agri-insurance for smallholder households. We also introduce new ways of thinking about the sector through deep dives, and propose a set of priority areas to guide work over the next 5 years.

Read More
Agricultural “Platforms” in a Digital Era: Defining the Landscape

We define the current landscape of agricultural Platforms, their risk and impact potential, and the path forward for supporting their growth.

View Report
State of the Sector: Pathways to Prosperity

This State of the Sector report identifies agenda-defining priorities that the sector must address to bridge the finance gap for smallholder households and agricultural SMEs, and introduces new models for navigating an increasingly sophisticated agricultural finance market.

View Report

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

1

In 2018, ISF Advisors, in partnership with the Syngenta Foundation, published Protecting Growing Prosperity: Agricultural Insurance in the Developing World. Alongside the release of that report, more than 100 industry stakeholders convened to consider solutions for maximizing the uptake and impact of insurance for smallholder farming households. However, since that time, the climate crisis has rapidly escalated and the disruptive effects of the COVID-19 pandemic have shifted market dynamics for smallholder farmers. These trends called for a new convening and reflection process for the sector. 

To that end, this 2022 State of the Sector update was commissioned by a new partnership of donors—including the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Syngenta Foundation, FSD Africa, and Swiss Re Foundation—and written by ISF Advisors with support from the Microinsurance Network. The findings of this report were shared and debated in a virtual industry convening of over 130 stakeholders in January 2022. Key ideas and reactions from these discussions have been captured in this report, which sets out to: 

  • Take stock of the current state of agri-insurance for smallholder households, distilling what has changed in the sector since 2018; 
  • Introduce new ways of thinking about the sector in the form of four deep dives; and 
  • Propose a set of priority areas to guide work over the next 5 years. 

We hope that this research will continue to support the insights, partnerships and investments needed to respond to the climate crisis, with smallholder farmers at the center of the action agenda. 

Related Research

State of the Sector: Agri-SME Finance

A new perspective on the agri-SME finance market: sizing and segmenting the market in new ways, reflecting on the rapidly accelerating imperative around climate, and identifying new priorities for action.

Read More
Agricultural “Platforms” in a Digital Era: Defining the Landscape

We define the current landscape of agricultural Platforms, their risk and impact potential, and the path forward for supporting their growth.

View Report
State of the Sector: Pathways to Prosperity

This State of the Sector report identifies agenda-defining priorities that the sector must address to bridge the finance gap for smallholder households and agricultural SMEs, and introduces new models for navigating an increasingly sophisticated agricultural finance market.

View Report

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

State of the Sector: Agri-SME Finance

A new perspective on the agri-SME finance market: sizing and segmenting the market in new ways, reflecting on the rapidly accelerating imperative around climate, and identifying new priorities for action.

Read More
State of the Sector: Agri-Insurance for Smallholder Farmers

A follow up to our 2018 Protecting Growing Prosperity report, we take stock of the current state of agri-insurance for smallholder households. We also introduce new ways of thinking about the sector through deep dives, and propose a set of priority areas to guide work over the next 5 years.

Read More
State of the Sector: Pathways to Prosperity

This State of the Sector report identifies agenda-defining priorities that the sector must address to bridge the finance gap for smallholder households and agricultural SMEs, and introduces new models for navigating an increasingly sophisticated agricultural finance market.

View Report

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

State of the Sector: Agri-SME Finance

A new perspective on the agri-SME finance market: sizing and segmenting the market in new ways, reflecting on the rapidly accelerating imperative around climate, and identifying new priorities for action.

Read More
State of the Sector: Agri-Insurance for Smallholder Farmers

A follow up to our 2018 Protecting Growing Prosperity report, we take stock of the current state of agri-insurance for smallholder households. We also introduce new ways of thinking about the sector through deep dives, and propose a set of priority areas to guide work over the next 5 years.

Read More
Agricultural “Platforms” in a Digital Era: Defining the Landscape

We define the current landscape of agricultural Platforms, their risk and impact potential, and the path forward for supporting their growth.

View Report

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

Effectiveness & Efficiency of Business Development Services (BDS) for Agri-SMEs

A study to identify and assess the efficiency and effectiveness of business development services (BDS) tools and methodologies provided to agri-SMEs in East and West Africa.

Read More
Assessing the Cost Efficiency and Effectiveness of Business Development Services for Agri-SMEs

A summary of key findings from our analysis of BDS tools and methodologies provided to agri-SMEs in East and West Africa.

Read More
Landscape Assessment of Agro-Industrial Parks in Uganda

Our landscape assessment in partnership with USAID’s Market Systems and Partnerships (MSP) Activity explores the primary opportunities for donors to further support the Government of Uganda’s ambitious agro-industrialization agenda, a key goal in its latest National Development Plan (NDPIII, 2020).

View Report

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

State of the Sector: Pathways to Prosperity

This State of the Sector report identifies agenda-defining priorities that the sector must address to bridge the finance gap for smallholder households and agricultural SMEs, and introduces new models for navigating an increasingly sophisticated agricultural finance market.

View Report
Foreign Currency Risk Management Strategies for Investment Vehicles

Our analysis for Small Foundation on available strategies for managing foreign currency risk in frontier and emerging markets is summarized in this report, which includes options at both the fund and investment level.

Read More
The Challenge of Climate Financing for Agri-SMEs

A summary of our latest research around how climate change is impacting agri-SMEs, and how capital and financial service providers can fill the significant unmet need for climate finance.

Read More

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

Role of Government in Rural and Agri-Finance: Transitioning to private sector involvement

Building on our 2014 analysis of the natural stages of agricultural finance, this briefing note interrogates more deeply the transition that countries make from government-led to more bank-led agricultural finance.

View Report
Landscape Assessment of Agro-Industrial Parks in Uganda

Our landscape assessment in partnership with USAID’s Market Systems and Partnerships (MSP) Activity explores the primary opportunities for donors to further support the Government of Uganda’s ambitious agro-industrialization agenda, a key goal in its latest National Development Plan (NDPIII, 2020).

View Report
How governments incentivize private sector involvement in agricultural finance

How can governments create and regulate space for the private sector in agricultural finance? Various countries have approached this challenge in different ways. By looking at different cases, we can uncover trends that might point governments in the right direction.

Read More

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Business development services (BDS) are critical in helping agricultural small and medium-sized enterprises (agri-SMEs) in emerging markets grow, improve productivity, strengthen resilience, and access necessary finance. Despite their importance, a more sophisticated model is needed to assess the cost efficiency and effectiveness of BDS programs in a comparative manner that can be applied across contexts and providers. 

Our latest work seeks to address this barrier by analyzing BDS tools and methodologies provided to agri-SMEs in East and West Africa. Through data analysis from 15 BDS providers, stakeholder interviews across the sector, and review of existing literature, this report builds on previous learnings to deepen best practices related to the needs of agri-SMEs and tools and approaches that could lead to improved BDS provision models.

BDS is effective & cost efficient in serving agri-SMEs

Overall, the study found that BDS provided to agri-SMEs is effective and cost efficient at improving outcomes related to revenue, employment, and capital raised. For enterprises in this study, the median cost of BDS provided was $2,724, which allowed those businesses to generate additional revenue, create new full-time employment (FTE) positions, and raise capital at rates multiple times the cost of the BDS.

For every $1 spent on BDS by providers, agri-SMEs generated $7 of additional revenue and raised $12 of capital. In addition, one new FTE position was created for every $617 spent on BDS.

There is a high degree of variation beneath these headline results based on the context of BDS provision (e.g., segment of recipient, objectives, market context). To further capture and explore some of these contextual nuances, the study establishes five key findings.

Finding 1: Key drivers of cost efficiency

Beneath the headline cost efficiency figures discussed above, enterprises experienced drastically different cost-efficiency outcomes based on the context of each service. While myriad factors drive the cost and efficiency of BDS provision, two primary factors were 1) the service delivery model (SDM) used and 2) the size of the enterprise being serviced — factors which were themselves intercorrelated. BDS delivered through group-based SDMs provide stronger value for money than individual SDMs in terms of outcomes of revenue and capital raised. BDS for micro and small firms is more cost efficient than BDS provided to medium-sized firms. These findings have implications for the way in which funders and providers view the efficient and effective provision of BDS. For example, group SDMs may be applicable or suitable (i.e., could drive increased cost efficiency) in more situations than currently used.

Finding 2: Enterprise fee coverage

Only 38% of the firms included in the study paid some amount for BDS received. Those that did pay for services experienced higher impact across all key metrics (e.g., revenue / FTE growth rate, revenue / FTEs created) than those not paying. Fee coverage was primarily driven by firm stage (later-stage firms more often pay fees than earlier stage firms) and SDM used (firms receiving individual SDMs tend to pay fees more often than those receiving other SDMs).

Finding 3: Segmentation approach

While BDS should be driven by enterprise-specific needs, segmenting recipients is crucial for determining the most relevant type of BDS at scale. This study finds that i) type of enterprise (e.g., cooperatives/producers vs. other agri-SMEs) and ii) maturity of enterprises are the two most commonly used segmentations. While there are numerous sophisticated segmentation approaches in existing literature, in practice providers most often use these more rudimentary approaches as a starting point (e.g., to select a broader cohort) prior to tailoring support on a more case-by-case basis.

Finding 4: Scale of provider

There is a significant gap in costs for delivering BDS and efficiency of outcomes between global (international organizations with multiple programs operating in various geographies) and local (smaller organizations operating in the region/country of its headquarters) providers. BDS via local providers ~$1k per enterprise and ~$4k via global organizations. In addition, local providers were 9X more cost efficient than global providers at boosting revenue and 10X more cost efficient in creating new jobs. These results appear to be driven by both differences in operational overhead and structure as well as varying program goals between the two types of providers.

Finding 5: Key challenges pertaining to the measurement & assessment of BDS

ISF Advisors worked closely with 15 BDS providers to collect and analyze case study data. Several recurring barriers and challenges were encountered throughout this process:

  1. Data quality and sophistication: the rigor and quality of data collection varied significantly across providers, resulting in cost and performance data that is difficult to compare across different contexts or types of provider.
  2. Assessment objectives and methodologies: differed significantly across the ecosystem and are often developed in an ad-hoc and isolated manner (e.g., driven by individual donors focused on specific contexts or outcomes).
  3. Alignment on qualitative definitions and terminology: while BDS innately encompasses a wide-variety of services, contexts, and objectives, providers rarely align on definitions and terminology, which makes comparison difficult.

Beyond these key findings, this study revealed significant opportunities for stakeholders across the market, particularly funders, to more fully consider cost efficiency when financing or providing BDS. Currently, the sector under emphasizes these factors, leading to wide variation in cost efficiency outcomes and, as a result, a continued focus on services which are not fully optimized. Funders in particular have an opportunity to further prioritize learning about the key drivers of cost and cost efficiency in general and across different segments. With greater understanding of these drivers, funders can support providers that are delivering services that are both effective and efficient.

The BDS sector’s emphasis on rigorous learning, model validation, and information sharing has unlocked deep impact for agricultural businesses and rural communities across the world. Now, a shift is needed to bring a greater appreciation for assessing cost efficiency and effectiveness in a comparative manner. Through more standardized measurement, and greater awareness of the importance of cost and cost efficiency, funders and providers can continue to improve BDS for even greater impact.

Related Research

Effectiveness & Efficiency of Business Development Services (BDS) for Agri-SMEs

A study to identify and assess the efficiency and effectiveness of business development services (BDS) tools and methodologies provided to agri-SMEs in East and West Africa.

Read More
SMEs in Food Systems: A Framework for Engagement

Our framework developed around the structure and key dynamics of food systems – focusing in particular on the role of agri-SMEs – and applied through two country studies in Colombia and Uganda to support the Argidius Foundation.

View Report
Landscape Assessment of Agro-Industrial Parks in Uganda

Our landscape assessment in partnership with USAID’s Market Systems and Partnerships (MSP) Activity explores the primary opportunities for donors to further support the Government of Uganda’s ambitious agro-industrialization agenda, a key goal in its latest National Development Plan (NDPIII, 2020).

View Report

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.

Related Research

State of the Sector: Agri-Insurance for Smallholder Farmers

A follow up to our 2018 Protecting Growing Prosperity report, we take stock of the current state of agri-insurance for smallholder households. We also introduce new ways of thinking about the sector through deep dives, and propose a set of priority areas to guide work over the next 5 years.

Read More
State of the Sector: Pathways to Prosperity

This State of the Sector report identifies agenda-defining priorities that the sector must address to bridge the finance gap for smallholder households and agricultural SMEs, and introduces new models for navigating an increasingly sophisticated agricultural finance market.

View Report
Assessment of investment funds supporting tropical forest areas and communities

Explores impact funds focused on forest-dependent communities and smallholder farmers, identifying best practices, gaps, and opportunities for investment to share with the broader impact investing community.

View Report

Want to learn more?

Contact us or sign up for our newsletter.